April 29, 2021
Paulo Steele*
The migration of consumer units from the Regulated Contracting Environment (ACR) to the free energy market changes distribution companies' energy balance, altering their energy-contracting needs. Given the prospect of this market's continued expansion, how might the current over-contracting scenario evolve over the next decade? To what extent could other power-sector conditions offset it? To discuss these questions, this article presents the effect of over-contracting on distribution companies' conditions, analyzes trends in the free market's evolution, and simulates its effects on companies' over-contracting conditions. Spoiler: ten years from now, the situation could look quite similar to today.
Reduced eligibility requirements for companies to become free consumers are opening the door for more and more medium-voltage captive loads to migrate. Today, becoming a free consumer requires at least 1,500 kW of contracted demand, dropping to 1,000 kW starting January 1, 2022, and 500 kW starting January 1, 2023. At the same time, tariff pressures are encouraging other consumers to migrate as free and special consumers.
But this evolution of the free market isn't the only factor that can affect the balance of distribution companies' energy contracts: the economic crisis, conditions imposed by the pandemic, allocating Firm Capacity Quota Contract (CCGF) quotas in volumes exceeding what's needed to replace contracts, the results of energy-efficiency programs, and the growth of Mini and Micro Distributed Generation (MMGD) also help explain the gap between expected electricity consumption in distribution concessions and the actual result.
It's worth remembering that, as a consequence of Normative Resolution No. 785, of October 10, 2017, CCGF quotas, which in December 2020 totaled 13.2 average GW, were still being reallocated among distribution companies.
Between 2015 and 2017, CCGF quotas were allocated in proportion to each distribution company's contractual exposure. Only starting in 2018, with the publication of Resolution 785/2017, in a four-year transition, would CCGF quotas be reallocated among distribution companies in proportion to each one's market.
Due to a combination of some of these factors, concessionaires already had, on average, an over-contracting level of 9% in 2019. Consumption reductions, mainly resulting from the Covid-19 pandemic, further intensified this scenario, with the average volume of surplus contracts reaching, by our calculations, about 17% in 2020.
In theory, only contractual surpluses up to the regulatory limit of 5% could be recognized in tariffs. However, there are market movements beyond distribution concessionaires' control and, therefore, beyond the regulatory limit. The fact is that, considering all tariff events carried out through December 2020, ANEEL has always classified all energy surpluses as involuntary, recognizing their impact on tariffs.
Since contractual surpluses are settled within the Electric Energy Trading Chamber (CCEE), the difference between the average contracting price of that energy and the Settlement Price of Differences (PLD), for better or worse, impacts application tariffs. This happens through the financial component known as the over-contracting pass-through.
A scenario where the average sale price for surpluses is higher than the average pass-through price of distribution companies' energy-purchase contracts (Pmix) results in financial surpluses when settling surpluses on the short-term market. These surpluses reduce the application tariffs associated with energy purchasing (TE). But if the PLD is below the Pmix, the opposite can happen.
Table 1 - Effect of Energy Surpluses on Distribution Companies' Financial Components
In an ACL-expansion scenario obtained through a simple linear regression using connection migrations over the last 12 months (dashed green line in Figure 1 below, describing an evolution trajectory at an average rate of 406 new connections per month), there could be more than 60,000 new ACL connections in 10 years. On the other hand, if a trend curve with a better correlation for the same period is used to describe this trajectory (dashed red line in Figure 1), the expected number of new connections for 2030 jumps to about 110,000 connections.
Figure 1 - Evolution of ACL Connections in the Country: Observed and Projected
Figure 2 - Medium-Voltage Energy Consumption Scenario in the ACL and ACR
In November 2020, of the total high-voltage energy consumed on distribution grids by units in subgroups A1, A2, and A3, about 95% of that energy was destined for the ACL. In medium voltage, however, considering subgroups A3a, A4, and AS, only 51% of consumed energy was destined for ACL loads.
Figure 3 - Share of ACL Connections in the Brazilian High-Voltage Distribution Market
Add to this the fact that, in terms of consumer units, 76% of high-voltage loads on distribution grids have already migrated to the ACL. In medium voltage, however, of the 194,000 consumer units, only 10% opted for the ACL.
Figure 4 - Share of ACL Connections in the Brazilian Medium-Voltage Distribution Market
The new free consumer will likely have a profile similar to today's special consumer. Currently, becoming a special consumer requires contracted demand equal to or greater than 500 kW. Through joint ownership, consumers with the same CNPJ (corporate taxpayer ID) or located in contiguous areas can combine their loads to reach the 500 kW demand level required to become a special consumer.
Table 2 - Characterization of Connections (Loads) in the ACL
In January 2021, there were 18,200 ACL connections with a special-consumer profile. These connections had a typical capacity of 540 kW, average demand of 250 kW, and, over the previous 12 months, grew within the ACL, in terms of number of connections, at an average rate of 2.5% per month.
Drawing on a lookalike1 modeling approach, we estimate that the ACR still has at least 110,000 connections engaged in commercial activities similar to those most frequently observed today in the ACL, and therefore eligible to opt into the free contracting environment.
So, knowing the typical demand for each economic activity that has already migrated lets us identify, by similarity, about 110,000 connections that could still migrate.
Considering the expected evolution trajectories for the number of new ACL connections for each of the 53 distribution concessionaires, limited to eligible connections obtained through lookalike modeling, we expect that, by the end of 2030, ACL connections will already total about 71,000 loads, consuming, on average, 23 GWh per month — a 66% increase over the average monthly consumption seen in the ACL in 2020.
Table 3 - Evolution Scenario for ACL Connections
Nobody knows exactly how the trajectory of captive consumer units migrating to the ACL will actually play out. But what we do know is that, in the recent past, these migrations contributed to changes in distribution companies' energy balance, also affecting their energy-contracting needs and companies' surplus levels.
Considering market-growth expectations of around 3.6% per year, as indicated by the National Electric System Operator (ONS), combined with our estimated annual migration growth rates and low-voltage MMGD growth of 4.6% and 21% per year, respectively, with only the current energy-decontracting mechanisms in place there's no reason to expect the current picture to change in a way that structurally alters electricity surplus levels.
On the other hand, what could ease distribution companies' elevated over-contracting scenario are the new products created for the Surplus Sales Mechanism (MVE) on December 18, 2020, under ANEEL Normative Resolution 904/2020.
Additionally, a possible supply-side change, removing energy from quota-regime plants from distribution companies' energy-purchasing portfolio, could help rebalance these companies' energy balance, even under extreme scenarios of change in electricity consumer-unit profiles.
In the short and medium term, a possible "removal from quota status" for Eletrobras' plants under the firm-capacity quota regime, as proposed under Provisional Measure No. 1,031/2021, would remove about 7,450 average MW from distribution companies' energy-purchasing portfolio. Additionally, under the review of Annex C of the Itaipu Treaty, more than 5,000 average MW could be reallocated from quota-holding distribution companies' portfolio.
So, given the trajectories of change in electricity consumer-unit profiles, if nothing changes in terms of energy supply over the coming years, distribution companies will keep seeing pre-MVE surplus levels that could exceed 30%. Since these over-contracting pass-throughs are carried out annually in tariff events, application tariffs will also remain at the mercy, for better or worse, of the difference between distribution companies' average energy-purchase contract price and the PLD.
** Paulo Steele is managing partner at TR Soluções, a technology company specializing in electricity tariffs.*
1The lookalike modeling approach adopted by TR Soluções helps identify CNPJs in the Federal Revenue Service's database by analyzing CCEE data on loads that have already migrated to the ACL. When the analysis process runs, the model looks for eligible CNPJs based on shared characteristics from the selected population of ACL connections.