September 1, 2023
Paulo Steele*
Transferring National Treasury funds to cover part of the Energy Development Account's (CDE) budget could reduce energy tariff variations by 0.5 percentage points in 2024 for every BRL 1 billion contributed. The simulation was run by TR Soluções based on a recent proposal along these lines put forward by the Minister of Mines and Energy, Alexandre Silveira.
The Energy Development Account (CDE) is a sector fund created by Law No. 10,438/2002, with the goal of providing resources to fund various public policies in the Brazilian power sector. This account's main revenue source is annual quotas paid by agents that serve end consumers, both captive and free, through charges passed on via the distribution and transmission system usage tariffs (TUSD and TUST).
In 2013, with the publication of Provisional Measure No. 579/2012, converted into Law No. 12,783/2013, there was a significant change in how CDE funds were formed and used. The fund's scope was expanded to include expenses previously covered by the General Reversion Reserve (RGR) and the Fuel Consumption Account (CCC). Additionally, the legislation eliminated cross-subsidies charged in each distribution company's application tariffs.
The transfer of National Treasury funds was also authorized, subject to provision in the Federal Budget, to cover part of the charge's costs. However, Treasury contributions only occurred in two years: the first in 2013, worth BRL 9.8 billion, and the second in 2014, worth BRL 11.9 billion. In 2015, without a Treasury contribution to rely on, the CDE budget rose 40% compared to the previous year's figure. As a result, that year application tariffs were repositioned by almost 40% on average, with the CDE's impact alone explaining about half of the tariff repositioning.
The CDE's main purposes are:
In the CDE's 2023 budget, costs under the account's responsibility totaled BRL 33.7 billion, resulting in an impact of BRL 85.98/MWh on residential consumer tariffs in the South, Southeast, and Center-West regions; and BRL 40.37/MWh on tariffs for those in the North and Northeast regions. It's worth noting that, in coming years, CDE-related tariff values should converge, following the transition in how the charge is allocated between the country's regions established by Law 13,360/2016.
Figure 1 - 2023 CDE Budget, in billions of BRL

As widely reported in the media, the Minister of Mines and Energy, Alexandre Silveira, said last Tuesday (8/29), in an interview after a public hearing at the Chamber of Deputies, that the government intends to send Congress a proposal to transfer to the Federal Budget CDE-budget costs not directly related to the energy sector.
Setting aside the debate over which costs would or wouldn't be directly related to the energy sector, it's possible to assess tariff scenarios for 2024 in light of these possible transfers.
Initially, without considering any change along these lines, TR Soluções expects the 2024 CDE budget to be BRL 36.6 billion. This estimate factored in the proposed budget for the More Light Program for 2024 (MME public consultation No. 154/2023) and funds tied to tariff discounts (subsidies for incentivized sources for Consumption, Generation, and Transmission, plus irrigation and economic subsidies to cooperatives) on the order of BRL 13.4 billion, along with the account's other costs.
For 2024, TR Soluções estimates the average variation in the Application Tariff attributed to residential consumers at around 4%, with the following expected distribution of average adjustments across Brazil's 51 electricity distribution concessionaires.
Figure 2 - Frequency distribution of average tariff repositioning in 2024

Figure 2 shows that, among the 51 distribution concessionaires, 23 are expected to see a negative tariff variation, or one of at most 4.7%, in 2024. The remaining 28 are expected to see increases between 5.4% and 20.7%.
In this simulation context, TR Soluções quantified new 2024 tariff values against three scenarios for transferring CDE costs to the Federal Budget: BRL 5 billion, BRL 10 billion, and BRL 15 billion.
The simulations show that, with transfers of these magnitudes, the average repositioning of residential consumers' application tariffs would move from the estimated 4% to average variations of, respectively, 1.43%, -1.10%, and -3.47%. In other words, on average, each BRL 1 billion transferred from the CDE budget to the Treasury could represent, in 2024, a tariff reduction of 0.5 pp.